Incredible When Was The First Madison Square Garden Built Ideas. It was demolished in 1926, and the new york life building, designed by cass gilbert and completed in 1928, replaced it. The second madison square garden was built in 1890 and demolished in 1925.

The garden's roots trace back to the northeast corner of madison square, where the first two madison square gardens stood, starting with the first, built in 1879. Morgan in 1889, madison square garden would take on a dramatic new look within a year of them acquiring it. Web the first madison square garden’s construction plan started in 1871, as p.t.